| Time *ET | Matchup | Prediction | Actual | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4:05 PM |  New York Yankees @ Boston Red Sox  J.A. Happ vs Travis Lakins -120 or 54.5% | Boston Red Sox win 60.4% of sims by 1.1 | New York Yankees wins 5-1 |  |
| 4:10 PM |  Arizona Diamondbacks @ Cincinnati Reds  Alex Young vs Luis Castillo -155 or 60.8% | Cincinnati Reds win 57.7% of sims by 0.6 | Arizona Diamondbacks wins 2-0 |  |
| 6:10 PM |  Kansas City Royals @ Miami Marlins  Danny Duffy vs Caleb Smith -106 or 51.5% | Miami Marlins win 51.8% of sims by 0.1 | Kansas City Royals wins 7-2 | |
| 6:10 PM |  Toronto Blue Jays @ Tampa Bay Rays  Anthony Kay vs Charlie Morton -260 or 72.2% | Tampa Bay Rays win 62.9% of sims by 1.1 | Tampa Bay Rays wins 5-3 |   |
| 7:05 PM |  Texas Rangers @ Baltimore Orioles  Jonathan Hernandez vs Aaron Brooks -105 or 51.2% | Baltimore Orioles win 50.8% of sims by 0.3 | Texas Rangers wins 9-4 | |
| 7:05 PM |  St. Louis Cardinals @ Pittsburgh Pirates  Adam Wainwright vs Steven Brault -145 or 59.2% | Pittsburgh Pirates win 60.9% of sims by 0.8 | St. Louis Cardinals wins 10-1 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Los Angeles Angels @ Chicago White Sox  Andrew Heaney vs Dylan Covey -140 or 58.3% | Los Angeles Angels win 53.7% of sims by 0.6 | Los Angeles Angels wins 8-7 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Cleveland Guardians @ Minnesota Twins  Aaron Civale vs Jake Odorizzi -135 or 57.4% | Cleveland Guardians win 53.5% of sims by 0.5 | Minnesota Twins wins 5-3 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Seattle Mariners @ Houston Astros  Yusei Kikuchi vs Justin Verlander -420 or 80.8% | Houston Astros win 80.2% of sims by 3.3 | Houston Astros wins 2-1 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Chicago Cubs @ Milwaukee Brewers  Yu Darvish vs Gio Gonzalez -122 or 55.0% | Chicago Cubs win 55.2% of sims by 0.7 | Milwaukee Brewers wins 3-2 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Philadelphia Phillies @ New York Mets  Drew Smyly vs Marcus Stroman -156 or 60.9% | New York Mets win 60.6% of sims by 0.6 | Philadelphia Phillies wins 5-0 | |
| 7:20 PM |  Washington Nationals @ Atlanta Braves  Austin Voth vs Julio Teheran -130 or 56.5% | Atlanta Braves win 57.5% of sims by 0.5 | Atlanta Braves wins 5-4 | |
| 8:40 PM |  Colorado Rockies @ San Diego Padres  Jeff Hoffman vs Joey Lucchesi -158 or 61.2% | San Diego Padres win 56.9% of sims by 0.4 | San Diego Padres wins 3-0 | |
| 9:07 PM |  Detroit Tigers @ Athletics  Jordan Zimmermann vs Chris Bassitt -320 or 76.2% | Athletics win 78.1% of sims by 2.9 | Athletics wins 10-2 | |
| 9:10 PM |  San Francisco Giants @ Los Angeles Dodgers  Tyler Beede vs Tony Gonsolin -240 or 70.6% | Los Angeles Dodgers win 69.7% of sims by 1.9 | San Francisco Giants wins 1-0 | |
Legend/Totals
| Correct Picks | 7 (46.7%) |
| Incorrect Picks | 8 (53.3%) |
| Final Margin within 5 Pts | 3 (20.0%) |
| Beat the Spread | 6 (40.0%) |
